He went out on a cookie run before his gig. We each chose one type of cookie. Chunky chocolate chip (me), Oreo (Whodunit), and iced oatmeal (Ponytail).
Later, Ponytail admitted that their fondness for oatmeal cookies has nothing to do with their taste (a taste they know I don't like).
"You don't have the same experience attached to them that we do," she explained.
"When we were little, we would spend lots of time with PawPaw, and he would always share his oatmeal cookies with us while we watched westerns together. Those are very happy memories."